In 1974 Tom 0'Toole purchased the property then known as the Ideal Cafe & Milk Bar. Three years later, Tom sold the business and moved to Augusta in Western Australia, where he made his mark as a leading country baker.

After returning to North East Victoria in 1984, Tom re-purchased his old Beechworth premises and the drapers next door and a frenzy of major building and renovations began. Production and baking areas at the rear were extended, and the former drapery premises opened up into the existing shop, doubling the floor space and entrances for customers. An outdoor area on the sidewalk was created to extend seating.

In 1992, the second storey and balcony were opened to the public and a BYO liquor license granted for these areas. Much care has been taken to preserve the original facade of the building which is situated in the heart of Beechworth.